APEC NEWS RELEASE: Issued by The APEC Business Advisory Council (ABAC) Ha Long, 29 July 2022 – Asia-Pacific business leaders in the APEC Business...
THE NZ/EU FTA IS LIKE THE CURATE’S EGG

In which we like the good parts of the NZ EU FTA….
Who remembers the curate’s egg? It’s when the nervous Curate, asked by the Bishop, if everything is ok with his boiled egg, replies “It’s good in parts, my Lord”. So too the recently concluded NZ/EU FTA, which has been some six years (and more) in the boiling. To have arrived at this moment has not been without the extraordinary efforts of New Zealand’s talented trade negotiators. To fault them would rightly risk the Bishop’s wrath. That a deal was concluded at all with the European Commission, representing 27 member states and 450 million consumers was something of a miracle, but there is no getting around the fact that while it is most certainly very good in parts, in others it is not.
That a deal was concluded at all with the European Commission, representing 27 member states and 450 million consumers was something of a miracle, but there is no getting around the fact that while it is most certainly very good in parts, in others it is not.
The good parts are very good
To accentuate the positive – the deal delivers tariff free access for a range of important export products to the EU, including apples, kiwifruit, other horticulture, honey, fish and wine, as well as better access for services and manufactured products. There are a range of other positives too – including a chapter on Māori economic co-operation, enhanced and enforceable provisions on sustainability as well as commitments on the digital economy including steps to promote paperless trade.
The undertaking of both parties to be held accountable for meeting Paris Climate Change commitments is a world-first, although how such a broad undertaking could be made actionable in a trade agreement is a little unclear.
The EU gets its share of the egg – it will enjoy tariff free access to the NZ market, better conditions for investment, including a higher investment screening threshold similar to other FTA partners, and better access to government procurement.
On intellectual property, the agreement does not extend patent protections for pharmaceuticals, something the EU would really have wanted but could have raise the cost of medicines. The copyright term will be extended but eleven years earlier than provided for in the NZ/UK FTA despite the protestations of many.
The not so good parts are, well, not good at all
Quite simply, despite the best efforts of negotiators, the FTA will not in the assessment of the exporters themselves deliver commercially meaningful outcomes for dairy and meat, which account for 40 percent of goods exports. They will gain access to only a marginal proportion of EU consumption (generally less than 1 percent). Even after full implementation, the dairy and meat sectors will face small quotas and high in-quota tariffs, restricting their ability to grow the market.
Yes admittedly some new access is granted for butter, cheese, milk powders and beef, but the levels are very small and the quota arrangements are likely to be difficult to meet. That means that the agreement’s usefulness in terms of encouraging more “trade diversification” (as the Government’s mantra goes) will be strictly limited. A lot of honey and onions will need to be sold to the EU to come anywhere close to the amount of dairy and meat sold to China. What’s more the deal sets a worrying precedent for future negotiations which may be no easier to conclude than with our old adversary the EU.
Who fettered my feta?
The EU has convinced New Zealand to adopt new regulations about the way certain geographical names are used in international trade – especially names associated primarily with dairy products, wine and some meat products. We wrote about this earlier here.
If anything the final agreement is less draconian than might have been feared, but it is regrettable that it includes some names which have become generic rather than related to a certain geography: the use of feta and prosecco will be prohibited and the use of parmesan and other terms will be limited to existing producers.
It’s fair enough to claim that this FTA was the best deal that could be obtained in the circumstances and that continuing negotiations might have led to a worse or even no outcome. That is a judgment call for the Government to make but while there are undoubtedly positives for New Zealand, when it comes to the dairy and meat sectors, there is understandable disappointment that a once-in-a-lifetime opportunity to set the conditions for trade in dairy and meat with the EU has not been realised. No wonder the curate is left feeling a little nervous when eating the Bishop’s egg.
This post was prepared by Stephen Jacobi, Executive Director of NZIBF.
REGISTER WITH TRADE WORKS
Register to stay up to date with latest news, as well as saving and discussing articles you’re interested in.
Latest News
Asia-Pacific Business Leaders to APEC Leaders: Speed up economic recovery and regain growth momentum
APEC NEWS RELEASE: Issued by The APEC Business Advisory Council (ABAC) Ha Long, 29 July 2022 – Asia-Pacific business leaders in the APEC Business Advisory Council (ABAC), meeting this week in Ha Long, Viet Nam, expressed deep concern about the unprecedented crises...
TradeWindow: Digital trade provides hope through challenging times
It won’t come as a surprise to many people to hear that we remain in a very challenging situation when it comes to global business. Our exporters are operating in an environment that is difficult to navigate due to continuing uncertainties – the seemingly endless...
TRADE AND CLIMATE POLICIES NEED TO WORK TOGETHER – BUSINESS FORUM
A new report, commissioned by the NZ International Business Forum (NZIBF) and prepared by Adrian Macey, former Climate Change Ambassador and World Trade Organization (WTO) Lead Negotiator, shows that trade policy and actions to address climate change can be...
Trade and Climate Change: State of Play
TRADE AND CLIMATE CHANGE: STATE OF PLAY. A discussion paper prepared for the NZIBF by Adrian Macey, June 2022. Download here.
ADDRESS TO THE FONTERRA ALUMNI GOVERNANCE DEVELOPMENT WORKSHOP
ADDRESS TO THE FONTERRA ALUMNI GOVERNANCE DEVELOPMENT WORKSHOP AUCKLAND, 29 JUNE 2022 STEPHEN JACOBI EXECUTIVE DIRECTOR NZ INTERNATIONAL BUSINESS FORUM THE GLOBAL GOVERNANCE CHALLENGE Thanks to my friend Janine Smith for inviting me to speak to you today....
NZ EU FTA – A MIXED BAG, SAYS BUSINESS FORUM
Reacting to the overnight conclusion of negotiations for a free trade agreement between New Zealand and the European Union, the NZ International Business Forum (NZIBF), which brings together a cross section of major exporters, said the outcome was mixed in terms of...
NZ EU FTA COMING DOWN TO THE WIRE – HOLD THE LINE, SAYS BUSINESS FORUM
As negotiations accelerate to conclude an ambitious free trade agreement between New Zealand and the European Union, the NZ International Business Forum (NZIBF), representing a cross section of major exporters, urges the Government and its negotiators to hold out for...
WTO BACK IN BUSINESS – INTERNATIONAL BUSINESS FORUM
Media release, 19 June 2022 The NZ International Business Forum (NZIBF) welcomes the outcome of the World Trade Organization (WTO) 12th Ministerial Council meeting in Geneva and congratulates Trade Minister O’Connor and officials. “It’s great to see the WTO back in...
Address to the 50th One Stop Update for the Accountant in Business
ADDRESS TO THE 50TH ONE STOP UPDATE FOR THE ACCOUNTANT IN BUSINESS CHRISTCHURCH, WELLINGTON, AUCKLAND, MAY 2022 STEPHEN JACOBI EXECUTIVE DIRECTOR NZ INTERNATIONAL BUSINESS FORUM ONE STOP GLOBAL ECONOMIC UPDATE Thanks to Brightstar for once again inviting me to...
Remarks by Rachel Taulelei to APEC Ministers Responsible for Trade, 21 May 2022
ABAC NEW ZEALAND REMARKS TO ABAC-MINISTERS RESPONSIBLE FOR TRADE DIALOGUE 21 MAY 2022 RACHEL TAULELEI ABAC NZ Chair, Ministers The Free Trade Area of the Asia Pacific (FTAAP) remains the preeminent economic priority for the Asia-Pacific business community. It...
Deepening ECONOMIC INTEGRATION and EQUIPPING BUSINESS FOR DYNAMIC, INCLUSIVE and SUSTAINABLE GROWTH ARE KEY to ECONOMIC RECOVERY, say business leaders
Vancouver, 28 April 2022 –Asia-Pacific business leaders in the APEC Business Advisory Council (ABAC), meeting this week in Vancouver, affirmed their determination to continue to work closely together to respond to the challenge of sustaining the region’s growth...
FROM APEC AND CPTPP TO IPEF – SMALL STEP OR GIANT LEAP?
The US idea of an Indo Pacific Framework (IPEF) continues to gain traction but is not without complication. Aotearoa-New Zealand is a great joiner - from the very beginning of the United Nations to the important economic institutions like the WTO, APEC, CPTPP and...
Remarks to Foreign Affairs, Defence and Trade Committee
NZ INTERNATIONAL BUSINESS FORUM REMARKS TO THE FOREIGN AFFAIRS, DEFENCE AND TRADE COMMITTEE INTERNATIONAL TREATY EXAMINATION OF THE NZ/UK FREE TRADE AGREEMENT 17 MARCH 2022 STEPHEN JACOBI EXECUTIVE DIRECTOR Madam Chair, Members of the Committee Thank you for the...
Submission to the Parliamentary Foreign Affairs, Defence and Trade Committee
INTERNATIONAL TREATY EXAMINATION OF THENEW ZEALAND UNITED KINGDOM FREE TRADE AGREEMENT MARCH 2022 Introduction and Summary 1. This submission is made on behalf of the New Zealand International Business Forum (NZIBF) whose members are listed at Annex A 1 . NZIBF is a...
BUSINESS FORUM COMMENDS RUSSIA SANCTIONS LEGISLATION
The NZ International Business Forum (NZIBF) has commended Parliament’s bipartisan Russia Sanctions legislation, targeting those involved in the invasion of Ukraine. “Tough times call for tough measures and this legislation is an appropriate response from New Zealand...