Stephen Jacobi presented to the Foreign Affairs, Defence and Trade Select Committee in support of the NZ/UAE Closer Economic Partnership. He emphasised the need for the Government to follow through on undertakings around paperless trade.
Are latest announcements of intended memberships a shot in the arm for the Trans Pacific trade deal – or a spanner in the works?
Way back at turn of the century the idea of what was to become the Trans Pacific Partnership (TPP) was but a glint in the eye of New Zealand Ministers and trade officials. It took twenty years to put in place this new trade fellowship, starting with New Zealand and Singapore (2001), then P4 with Brunei and Chile (2006) before TPP-12 (2016), and ultimately, after the United States departed the company, “the Comprehensive and Progressive Agreement for Trans Pacific Partnership” (2018).
Now three more economies are seeking to join – the United Kingdom, which takes the vision beyond the Asia Pacific; China, which significantly magnifies the Agreement’s economic punch; and Chinese Taipei, which qualifies for membership as a separate customs territory. Other economies, including Korea and Thailand, may well be in the wings. This has clearly been a long term vision. Despite one large and deeply regrettable reversal of fortune, the strategy appears to be working – that is, to build an ambitious, high quality and comprehensive agreement as a pathway to a broader Free Trade Area of the Asia Pacific and as a spur to global trade liberalisation.
What’s behind China’s bid?
Much attention was focused last week on China’s sudden announcement of intention to join. This was not completely unexpected – the Chinese leadership had signaled as early as June last year that it wanted to explore CPTPP – but the timing was exquisite, coming hard on the heels of a new security partnership announced by the US, UK and Australia. Before beginning the accession process all eleven members need to assure themselves that China can meet the high CPTPP standards. This includes not just the trade rules, but also the market access interests of the other members. In New Zealand’s case our FTA already gives us very favourable market access to China. CPTPP is unlikely to give us more unless Chinese membership were to come before 2024, when the remaining dairy safeguard tariffs are due to be phased out. But like other members, we have a strong interest in seeing China play by the rules and, as we said back in June 2020, CPTPP is a way of ensuring that China’s future economic development follows internationally agreed norms and standards.
Political theatre, or something more?
Some commentators especially in the US have been quick to dismiss China’s bid as political theatre designed to frustrate the achievement of CPTPP’s goals. It’s true that in relation to digital trade and data flows, state owned enterprises, intellectual property and labour, to name just a few areas, China will need to contemplate some serious reforms. Doubtless the Chinese are thinking that they may be able to negotiate their way through this – if so, their position is not so different from the US which has said it “may” (one day…) seek to rejoin, but only if the rules can be changed (and it should be added if Congress grants a new Trade Promotion Authority). It is hard to believe though that the Chinese have taken this step on the expectation that they won’t have to do anything at all. Their bid is not risk-free. They are putting their trade regime up for international scrutiny in a way they have not done since they joined the World Trade Organisation (WTO) – a rebuff would be a significant loss of face, for very little gain. If on the other hand the Chinese leadership is serious about reforms in key areas, then CPTPP provides just what the world needs at this point – a way to engage with a rising China on matters of national interest where China has every reason to co-operate.
If on the other hand the Chinese leadership is serious about reforms in key areas, then CPTPP provides just what the world needs at this point – a way to engage with a rising China on matters of national interest where China has every reason to co-operate.
It’s true too that political differences could well overshadow China’s bid. Australia and China are pitted against each other in a series of WTO disputes, but Australia could use the bid to seek direct discussions with China which have earlier been rebuffed. Canada’s relationship with China is also frosty, but its significant economic interests may be assisted by a more positive engagement. Then there is the ticking time bomb of USMCA Trade Agreement and the provision that seeks to restrict the ability of the US, Mexico and Canada to negotiate FTAs with non-market economies – this too will need to be tested.
Meanwhile in Taipei …
The bid by Chinese Taipei, announced days after that of China, also presents a challenge. New Zealand like Singapore has a very successful FTA with the Separate Customs Territory of Taiwan, Penghu, Kinmen and Matsu, which should position Chinese Taipei well for CPTPP membership. China has already indicated its strong disapproval, which may yet play out badly. Possibly the process used to engineer Chinese Taipei’s membership of the WTO, whereby they joined immediately after China, could work with CPTPP, but for the time being at least the process requires applications to be handled on separate tracks.
Good things take time
CPTPP is unusual in that it has no permanent Secretariat. While New Zealand serves as the depositary (a kind of mail-box) for the Agreement, the accession process is handled by the Chair of the Commission. Japan currently holds this role and will be succeeded by Singapore at the end of the year (and New Zealand in 2023). The UK application, being the first under procedures adopted in January 2019 is already taking up a lot of time and effort. These further applications and the complex issues they will give rise to, are likely to weigh heavily on the system.
While it may seem like things never change much in trade, occasionally some big things happen. This has been the history of TPP from the very beginning. Last week was a big week for CPTPP and who knows, maybe for the future of trade in the Asia Pacific and beyond.
Note: CPTPP Members are (* denotes yet to ratify): Australia, Brunei*, Canada, Chile*, Japan, Malaysia* Mexico, New Zealand, Peru, Singapore and Viet Nam.
CPTPP accession procedures are outlined here and in a handy graphic produced by the Peterson Institute here.
This post was prepared by Stephen Jacobi, Executive Director of the NZ International Business Forum.
REGISTER WITH TRADE WORKS
Register to stay up to date with latest news, as well as saving and discussing articles you’re interested in.
Latest News
REMARKS TO FOREIGN AFFAIRS, DEFENCE AND TRADE COMMITTEE – 20 FEBRUARY 2025
RATIFICATION OF NEW ZEALAND-UAE COMPREHENSIVE ECONOMIC PARTNERSHIP AGREEMENT (CEPA) STEPHEN JACOBI, EXECUTIVE DIRECTOR, NZIBF Thank you Chair for the opportunity to appear before the Committee today. I do so on behalf of the members of the NZ International Business...
Submission by ExportNZ and TradeWorks to the Health Select Committee on the Gene Technology Bill
17th February 2025 Our Recommendations ExportNZ and the New Zealand International Business Forum (NZIBF) support the Government’s overall intention to modernise New Zealand’s gene technology regulations. We support the establishment of a risk-based regulatory regime...
SUBMISSION TO THE FOREIGN AFFAIRS, DEFENCE AND TRADE SELECT COMMITTEE
RATIFICATION OF NEW ZEALAND-UAE COMPREHENSIVE ECONOMIC PARTNERSHIP AGREEMENT (CEPA) FEBRUARY 2025 This submission is made on behalf of the New Zealand International Business Forum (NZIBF) and ExportNZ[1]. NZIBF is a forum of senior business leaders working together...
SOUTHERN LINK REVISITED SEMINAR, SEPT 2024
On 24 September 2024 a stakeholders seminar was held in Auckland to reassess the Southern Link concept, five years after a large conference kickstarted focused discussion of the idea (before Covid intervened). This report of the seminar discussions...
T Day has come
STOP PRESS – NOT SO FAST. This post deals with the tariffs President Trump announced on 1 February he would impose on Canada, Mexico and China. By 4 February he announced imposition of tariffs on Canada and Mexico would be suspended for 30 days (until 5 March). ...
Back to the future?
The end of 2024 has trade advocates reaching back to their 2016 taking points as an Administration of a depressingly protectionist hue prepares to take office in the United States, once the global champion for trade liberalisation. We do not know for now what,...
Diplosphere: Tour de Force with Stephen Jacobi – Having Choice is a Key NZ Interest
Stephen Jacobi on APEC, WTO, doubling trade exports, big ideas like Southern Link, independent thinking & risks of a red line with AUKUS P2. This interview was recorded on Tue 19 Nov, 2024 in Wellington, NZ at Diplosphere HQ. Watch the full video here.
APEC Business Leaders Call for Bold Actions on Sustainable Growth and Economic Integration
Read the original article on the ABAC website here. Lima, 12 November 2024 — With challenges becoming increasingly borderless, business leaders from across the Asia-Pacific region are calling on APEC Leaders to take decisive actions to boost sustainable and inclusive...
CPTPP and the art of living dangerously
By Stephen Jacobi [1] As published by Newsroom, 6 December 2024 There’s not much shouting about TPP these days, but more passion would be a good thing. Time was when “TPPA” could bring tens of thousands to the streets. These days the annual Ministerial meeting...
NZIBF 2024 Chair Report
I am pleased to present my fourth report on the activities and achievements of the NZ International Business Forum (NZIBF) for 2023-24, our 17th year of operations. I am grateful to all Board and associate Members for your continuing commitment and support. This...
Reimagining the trans-Tasman relationship for two decades
Even the closest of relationships require advocacy. That applies equally to Australia – our greatest friend. That’s the job of the Australia New Zealand Leadership Forum (ANZLF), whose Steering Committee met in Sydney last week. The ANZLF has come a long...
THE NEXT BIG IDEA – THE SOUTHERN LINK
If New Zealand is serious about doubling export value in the next ten years then we need some really big, new ideas. Doing more of the same, not that there is anything wrong with that, is just going to deliver the same result. Enter an idea whose time has...
ADDRESS TO THE 55TH ONE STOP UPDATE FOR THE ACCOUNTANT IN BUSINESS – GLOBAL ECONOMIC UPDATE
AUCKLAND, 21 OCTOBER 2024 STEPHEN JACOBI, EXECUTIVE DIRECTOR, NZ INTERNATIONAL BUSINESS FORUM Watch the video of the address here. Introduction Thanks to Brightstar for the opportunity to be with you again, in person this time! I’ve spoken several times now at this...
NZ/GCC FREE TRADE AGREEMENT – EXPANDING OPPORTUNITIES IN THE GULF
Building on earlier negotiations with the United Arab Emirates, New Zealand’s successful conclusion of negotiations for a NZ/Gulf Co-operation Council Free Trade Agreement should enable further expansion of trade with the GCC’s six members in the Middle East, says the...
TIES THAT BIND – EXPANDING CER TO ASEAN
For New Zealand to pay more attention to the economies of ASEAN (the ten-member Association of South East Asian nations) makes sense, particularly at a time when doing business around the world is tough and when we need all of our international connections to deliver...