Stephen Jacobi gave a geo-political, trade and consumer update at the NZ Apples and Pears Inc Conference.
SPOTLIGHT ON SUBSIDIES
![01](https://www.tradeworks.org.nz/wp-content/uploads/2024/08/01-scaled.jpeg)
With much of the world turning inwards and the World Trade Organisation (WTO) in a parlous state, it could be tempting to relax New Zealand’s long-term struggle to rid the world of trade-distorting, environmentally harmful and financially wasteful subsidies. Not so says the Dairy Companies Association of New Zealand (DCANZ) which has commissioned some new research “Levelling the playing field” to examine the impact of agricultural subsidies on global dairy trade.
Doesn’t everyone do it?
Let’s be frank – over the last fifty years one of the big impacts on the environment for New Zealand’s dairy trade has been the pernicious use of subsidies, often by partners in Europe, North America and latterly Asia who have been amongst our closest friends. Subsidies have distorted markets, reduced returns for our industry and held back economic development here in New Zealand.
Over the last fifty years one of the big impacts on the environment for New Zealand’s dairy trade has been the pernicious use of subsidies, often by partners in Europe, North America and latterly Asia who have been amongst our closest friends.
New Zealand consistently ranks amongst the lowest in the OECD in terms of its support to farmers. But despite some success at the WTO of reining in export subsidies, we are a long way off dealing once and for all with the subsidies problem. Today the OECD puts support to agriculture at a staggering USD 851 billion per year in 2020-22 across OECD members and major emerging economies. Spending is growing – and so too is the distortionary effect on trade and markets.
Why this research ?
Dairy is one of the world’s most heavily protected sectors. And while there is quite a lot of analysis about the role of tariffs in distorting markets and adding costs to trade, understanding of the impact of direct farm spending on global dairy markets is much less well understood. Hence the focus of the DCANZ multi-year project[1]: it aims to strengthen the evidence base for further reform of trade rules around domestic support, which are largely set through the WTO.
The centre piece of the project is a Global Dairy Distortions Model. This is an economic model of dairy trade aimed identifying the effects that policies have on dairy production and trade, and quantifying the effects of potential policy changes.
The model has already shown:
- The impact of a 2020 intervention by the EU in skim milk powder cost New Zealand farmers $44,000 per average sized farm
- Subsidies by OECD members cost New Zealand $66 million each year in lost revenue – about the same as levies of $67 million paid by farmers to Dairy NZ
- The impact of EU subsidies for cheese was an 8 percent suppression in prices.
These are not small numbers and they are all the more serious in view of the highly protected nature of dairy markets around the world. Some 87% of global consumption of dairy products takes place behind tariffs of 20 percent or more.
What can be done now?
The old adage is relevant: “what gets measured gets done”. What’s clear is that the overhang of subsidies on global markets still matters, even for those subsidies we thought were less trade-distorting. That’s the value of this new analytical tool – we can assess what the real world impacts are. What is also clear is that Government and industry need to work together to continue to press the case, even in this highly contested environment. We should not give up on global rule-making in this space but we need new ideas and new analysis, especially in the context of next year’s WTO Ministerial, to bring these material issues back on the table.
This post was prepared by Stephen Jacobi, Executive Director of the NZ International Business Forum. They are based on remarks he gave to a DCANZ seminar focused on the research held in Wellington on 5 August 2024. Further information on the research and model can be found at www.dcanz.com/gddm.
[1] The DCANZ project has been co-funded by the New Zealand Ministry of Primary Industries Sustainable Food and Fibre Futures Fund. The project and model have been completed by Sense Partners.
REGISTER WITH TRADE WORKS
Register to stay up to date with latest news, as well as saving and discussing articles you’re interested in.
Latest News
Address to NZ Apples and Pears Inc Conference, 30 July
GEO-POLITICAL, TRADE AND CONSUMER UPDATE Stephen Jacobi, Executive Director, NZ International Business Forum Introduction Thanks to the team at NZ Apples and Pears for the invitation to be with you today. I’m here to talk about the bigger picture against which your...
NON TARIFF BARRIERS – “YOU ARE NOT ALONE”
Non- tariff barriers (NTBS) have a pernicious effect on trade. Sometimes it seems that just as tariffs go down, an NTB springs up! They can be hard to identify and even harder to address. The red meat industry, New Zealand’s second largest export...
INTERNATIONAL TREATY EXAMINATION OF THE AGREEMENT ON THE INDO-PACIFIC ECONOMIC FRAMEWORK FOR PROSPERITY
SUBMISSION TO THE FOREIGN AFFAIRS, DEFENCE AND TRADE SELECT COMMITTEE - JULY 2024 Introduction This submission is made on behalf of the New Zealand International Business Forum (NZIBF) and ExportNZ. NZIBF, whose members are listed at Annex A,[1] is a forum of...
Sourcing from the world’s factory – new research report into imports from China
There are very few strategic risks to New Zealand from our current levels of exposure to imports from China, concludes a new report from the New Zealand China Council, co-sponsored by NZIBF. Even if we were to diversify our sources, China is now so...
ADDRESS TO THE 54TH ONE STOP UPDATE FOR THE ACCOUNTANT IN BUSINESS – GLOBAL ECONOMIC UPDATE
AUCKLAND, WELLINGTON, CHRISTCHURCH, MAY 2024 STEPHEN JACOBI, EXECUTIVE DIRECTOR - NZ INTERNATIONAL BUSINESS FORUM Introduction Thanks once again to Brightstar for the opportunity to address you today. I’m sorry I can’t be with you in person as I am travelling...
APEC Ministers Responsible for Trade Joint Statement 2024
2024 APEC Ministers Responsible for Trade Joint Statement Arequipa, Peru | 18 May 2024 We, the Asia-Pacific Economic Cooperation (APEC) Ministers Responsible for Trade (MRT), met in Arequipa, Peru on 17-18 May 2024, chaired by Peru’s Minister of Foreign Trade and...
Business Forum welcomes UAE FTA negotiations
Media release, 7 May 2024 The NZ International Business Forum (NZIBF) welcomes the start of formal negotiations on the New Zealand/UAE Closer Economic Partnership Agreement (CEPA) and looks forward to steady progress that will lead to the securing of a comprehensive...
Doubling our exports with zeroes…and ones!
The development of written language in the ancient world didn’t start with great poetry or literary epics. The catalyst for writing was the need to record the transfer of the ownership of goods from one person to another. Scribes did this by marking tablets of clay...
Asia-Pacific business leaders rally for robust global trade amidst rising protectionism
APEC NEWS RELEASE Issued by The APEC Business Advisory Council (ABAC) - April 2024 This week in Hong Kong, China, the APEC Business Advisory Council (ABAC) voiced serious concerns regarding the global shift towards protectionism and regional fragmentation, risking...
SUBMISSION TO THE MINISTRY OF FOREIGN AFFAIRS AND TRADE – APRIL 2024
NEW ZEALAND-UAE COMPREHENSIVE ECONOMIC PARTNERSHIP AGREEMENT NEGOTIATIONS This submission is made on behalf of the New Zealand International Business Forum (NZIBF), whose members are listed at Annex A[1]. NZIBF is a forum of senior business leaders working together...
NEW TEAM FOR AUSTRALIA NEW ZEALAND LEADERSHIP FORUM
Media release, 2 April 2024 The New Zealand Co-Chair of the Australia New Zealand Leadership Forum (ANZLF), Greg Lowe, welcomes the appointment of Stephen Jacobi and Simon Le Quesne to the New Zealand arm of the ANZLF Secretariat. The ANZLF brings business leaders,...
NZ/EU FTA A BONUS FOR SOME SECTORS – BUSINESS FORUM
Media release, 22 March 2024 The NZ International Business Forum (NZIBF) acknowledges the passage of the implementing legislation for the New Zealand/European Union Free Trade Agreement and looks forward to the FTA’s entry into force on 1 May. “This agreement was...
“MEAGRE OUTCOME” FROM WTO IN ABU DHABI – BUSINESS FORUM
Media release, 2 March 2024 Despite its overwhelming importance at the heart of the international trade system, members of the World Trade Organisation (WTO) have concluded their Ministerial in Abu Dhabi (“MC13”) with only a meagre outcome. NZ International Business...
To go or woe with the WTO?
We’ve been here before with the World Trade Organisation (WTO). The global trade body’s 13th Ministerial meeting (“MC13”) opens in Abu Dhabi on Monday 26 February, with Trade Minister McClay serving as Vice-Chair. In recent weeks diplomats, trade...
DCANZ – Agricultural Subsidy Distortions Must Be Addressed
23 February 2024 - Media Release by the Dairy Companies Association of New Zealand (DCANZ) As the world’s Trade Ministers head to a WTO meeting in Abu Dhabi, the Dairy Companies Association of New Zealand (DCANZ) is calling for an immediate capping of agricultural...