“The greatest FTA ever negotiated”

by | Oct 2, 2018 | Trade Working Blog

Remove

If you know your French history, in 1789, Louis XVI, asked his courtiers “Is this a revolt” and they replied: “No Sire, it is a revolution”. In 2018 President Donald J Trump asked his courtiers to deliver a revolution in North American trade. What he got was a revolt of sorts, but one with limited impact, at least for now.

Channeling the Village People, “USMCA” (the US Mexico Canada Agreement) will replace the North American Free Trade Agreement (NAFTA) which entered into force in 1994. Business groups, especially in Canada, will breathe a sigh of relief. Despite tweaks here and there, USMCA is unlikely to disturb unduly the extensive integration between the three amigos in North America, except perhaps in terms of the motor vehicle industry where the changes are a little more extensive. Mostly though some of the world’s most competitive supply and value chains will continue as before and that is a good thing for industry, workers and consumers in that part of the world.

The deal does have some implications for New Zealand interests though:

  • US dairy farmers will gain some additional access to the Canadian market, not a great deal more than under the former TPP and certainly not enough to bring down Canada’s extensive supply management for dairy
  • Canada will phase out its “special milk class 7” scheme under which Canada was able to supply subsidised milk powder to global markets – that will be welcomed by New Zealand exporters
  • Canada will rein in British Columbia’s scheme to allow sales of BC wine in supermarkets, while imported wines were relegated to specialty stores – this was a WTO dispute in the making and will assist NZ exporters. It remains to be seen whether Canadian restrictions on the distribution of wine in other provinces will be reformed
  • The operation of controversial investor-state dispute settlement (ISDS) will no longer apply between the United States and Canada (but will continue between the United States and Mexico)
  • The US has extended the intellectual property provisions of the former TPP which were stripped out of CPTPP.

The latter two elements make it both easier and harder to negotiate a future FTA between the US and New Zealand. While the elimination of ISDS will be welcomed by the NZ Government, intellectual property remains a real sticking point.

One other provision is potentially hu-uge. The USMCA parties have agreed to consult and potentially withdraw commitments if one of them negotiates an FTA with a non-market economy (read: China). This is unusual for an FTA and calls into question future Canadian and Mexican support for the Free Trade Area of the Asia Pacific (FTAPP) which has been on APEC’s agenda for over a decade.

Revolutions in international trade seldom happen overnight. The devil is in the detail and the effects accumulate over time. It will doubtless prove so with USMCA but that it got done at all in the current trade climate is probably something to raise a royal eyebrow.

This post was written by Stephen Jacobi, Executive Director of the NZ International Business Forum.

REGISTER WITH TRADE WORKS

Register to stay up to date with latest news, as well as saving and discussing articles you’re interested in.

 

Remove

 

Latest News

TIES THAT BIND – EXPANDING CER TO ASEAN

For New Zealand to pay more attention to the economies of ASEAN (the ten-member Association of South East Asian nations) makes sense, particularly at a time when doing business around the world is tough and when we need all of our international connections to deliver...

SPOTLIGHT ON SUBSIDIES

With much of the world turning inwards and the World Trade Organisation (WTO) in a parlous state, it could be tempting to relax New Zealand’s long-term struggle to rid the world of trade-distorting, environmentally harmful and financially wasteful subsidies.  Not...

Address to NZ Apples and Pears Inc Conference, 30 July

GEO-POLITICAL, TRADE AND CONSUMER UPDATE Stephen Jacobi, Executive Director, NZ International Business Forum Introduction Thanks to the team at NZ Apples and Pears for the invitation to be with you today. I’m here to talk about the bigger picture against which your...

NON TARIFF BARRIERS – “YOU ARE NOT ALONE”

Non- tariff barriers (NTBS) have a pernicious effect on trade.  Sometimes it seems that just as tariffs go down, an NTB springs up!  They can be hard to identify and even harder to address.  The red meat industry, New Zealand’s second largest export...

Business Forum welcomes UAE FTA negotiations

Media release, 7 May 2024 The NZ International Business Forum (NZIBF) welcomes the start of formal negotiations on the New Zealand/UAE Closer Economic Partnership Agreement (CEPA) and looks forward to steady progress that will lead to the securing of a comprehensive...

Doubling our exports with zeros…and ones!

Image credit: Gerd Altmann, Pixabay The development of written language in the ancient world didn’t start with great poetry or literary epics. The catalyst for writing was the need to record the transfer of the ownership of goods from one person to another. Scribes...